Monday, March 4, 2013

Blog 3: Writing An Editorial


Teenage Prisoners Describe Hurricane Horrors


Published: May 10, 2006



More than 100 teenagers were held in a detention center for days on end days after Hurricane Katrina struck. They were given to food or water to drink, causing many of them to pass out out from dehydration. They were roped together by plastic handcuffs and led in high water, to their destination. "The report described what happened after the storm as symptomatic of a juvenile justice system recognized as one of the country's worst, an outpost of a sprawling prison empire where more people were locked up, per capita, than in any other state." 6 years later, the Justice Department control passed a law that would not allow this event or any events of this likeness to happen again.
I strongly disagree with the fact that Louisiana waited 6 years after the hurricane to bring this horrible subject up again, in court and get something changed about it. I don't understand why it took so long for them to get a law made against keeping youth against their will in detention or prison cells, under any circumstance. I understand that Louisiana needed to do many investigations to be sure there theories were correct, but it shouldn't have taken 6 years. In the article, it states, "Several youth prisons in the state had achieved infamy as places of routine beatings and systematic deprivation, and federal authorities concluded that conditions were unconstitutional." Even federal authorities knew that the conditions that these youth experienced were terribly wrong and un-just.

My opinion about the whole article is that it was morally wrong to take these teenagers to prison and lock them up in cells. It was morally wrong to leave them stranded, in detention, standing in the flood waters for days, without food or clean water. When I hear stories about these kinds of things happening, I had a hard time comprehending it because it's such a shock to me that there are people in the world that would actually do that to teenagers. The youth were miserable; terrified out of their skin. It says in the article, "Kids were going crazy, shaking their cells for food and water." "We went five days without eating. Kids were passing out in their cells." Kids were dropping like flies there and no one seemed to care about them and their situations the slightest bit.

I believe that the people of Louisiana who put the teenagers in prison, held the hostage, and didn't let them have any food or water were morally wrong with with their actions. They were not thinking straight, in my opinion. They were acting out of the heat of the moment, not out of logical thinking. I believe that the state of Louisiana put into place a very good and beneficial law to ban holding teenagers and sending them to prison without further questioning those who look suspicious. I do not think it was a good idea to wait 6 years to put this law in place. Louisiana could have passed that law sooner, so it would take affect sooner.

http://www.nytimes.com/2006/05/10/us/10prison.html?_r=0   -link to article
o

No comments:

Post a Comment